Audio & Podcasts

The Box of Delights – Audio Drama Review

First Published in 1935, The Box of Delights – John Masefield’s sequel to his earlier book, The Midnight Folk – has enjoyed many adaptations over the past 85 years. These have tended to be of excellent quality, so much so that for many, if not most who know it, The Box of Delights isn’t really a book, but instead a beloved television series produced by the BBC in 1984.

Now Big Finish have thrown their Christmas cracker paper hat into the ring with an audio adaptation penned by Christopher William Hill. It’s familiar territory for Hill, who was responsible for the excellent BBC Radio adaptation of The Midnight Folk, and he brings that deeper understanding of the characters and the world Masefield created to bear.

The respect shown for the original story, as well as the various adaptations that fans have come to love, is clear. For example, the opening of each episode uses The First Nowell section from the Carol Symphony by Victor Hely-Hutchinson. First used in the Children’s Hour adaptation in 1943, it’s a piece that manages to go from unsettling and sinister to heralding the arrival of Christmas in less than a bar. Not using it would have felt like a betrayal, and hearing those opening notes is like a reassuring hug.

READ MORE: Futtocks End and Other Short Stories – Blu-ray Review

That appreciation of the responsibility an adaptation like this creates is evident throughout. At almost five hours, this is a lengthy production. Fortunately, it’s broken up into ten separate parts. If you can resist bingeing – which isn’t going to be easy – this feels like the ideal treat for putting on as you wrap presents and prepare food during the run up to Christmas. That extra time has allowed Hill to explore the source material far more deeply than other adaptations. There’s more 1930’s slang, more moments of magic, and more reasons to fall in love with the story.

Big Finish have again drawn on their regular stable of amazing talent, but it’s rare to see so many of their big guns in one production; another mark of how seriously this has been taken. Mack Keith-Roach and Lizzie Waterworth-Santo are brilliant as Kay and Peter, respectively. There is a warmth and friendship between them that elevates their characters from two-dimensional protagonists to people we care about, wonderfully heightening the tension when danger threatens, and making it easier to smile when their idiosyncrasies come out.

Derek Jacobi brings a nuanced warmth to the role of Cole Hawlings. The affable Punch & Judy man-cum-immortal magician needs to be someone we easily trust, and Jacobi plays the part wonderfully. Clare Corbett’s rebellious Maria sounds rather too much like an adult doing an impression of Violet Elizabeth Bott from the Just William TV series. It’s fine, but doesn’t gel with the rest of the production, especially when heard alongside Deeivya Meir’s far more naturalistic Susan.

READ MORE: Doctor Who: The War Doctor Begins – ‘Forged In Fire’ – Audio Drama Review

Louise Jameson, Nicholas Pegg, and Damian Lynch make up Abner’s gang of Pouncer, Charlie, and Chubby Joe. The trio create a near pantomime level of villainy, and it’s almost impossible to really dislike them, which is exactly what is needed. Lynch is particularly good value playing the part of the slow-witted lackey, wringing every drop of humour from an already funny character.

Three relatively small but vital roles have been cast with excellent actors able to bring the necessary punch to what they are doing. Tim Bentinck gives us a loveable, bumbling, yet ultimately heroic Inspector, and hearing David Warner’s turn as Arnold of Todi is nothing short of a joy. A  favourite of the Big Finish regulars, Mina Anwar uses her natural warmth and humor to bring a likeable believability to the much put upon character of Ellen.

Lisa Bowerman as Caroline Louisa has little to do other than sound posh and unflappable, but she does do that well, while the rest of the voice cast perform an amazing job, ensuring we continue to believe and enjoy the whole experience. The best has been left to last, and Mark Gatiss deserves nothing short of a knighthood for his outstanding work as the main baddie, Abner Brown. Practically chewing on every syllable he spits out, his portrayal is a worthy successor to Robert Stephens, which is as high a praise as can be given.

READ MORE: Screaming Queens! – Audio Drama Review

But beyond the epic script and outstanding cast, the production values are sumptuous in their own right. An excellent soundscape creates detailed and rich images, though at times it can be a little jarring. For example, at one point popping chestnuts sounded more like gun-fire. But that small gripe aside, it’s a well realised world that draws you into it.

The soundtrack manages to be even better. Unobtrusive incidental music interweaves beautifully with rousing snippets of classic carols that provoke an immediate emotional response. It might occasionally stray a little too close to John Williams at Hogwarts territory, which can distract, but that’s entirely forgivable. One of the special features is an eleven minute long suite of the music, which should become your go to soundtrack when out Christmas shopping. It’s clear that director Barnaby Edwards knows exactly what he wants to achieve: nostalgia for a time none of us ever knew yet still remember.

READ MORE: Thunderbirds: Terror From The Stars – Audio Drama Review

Along with the musical suite, you get to enjoy an hour long behind the scenes special feature, full of information and interviews that starts with the heartwarming revelation that the idea of using Derek Jacobi in a children’s Christmas story sparked the entire project. It only gets better from there.

Released in June, that is not the time to enjoy this story unless you are a die-hard fan. But cometh the hour, cometh the man or, in this case, cometh the season, cometh the audio adaptation. This is old fashioned, perfect Christmas fare. A spiffing world of adventures had by young people with received pronunciation between sumptuous meals of potted meat sandwiches and pop. Local bobbies, crisp snow, and parcels wrapped with brown paper and string. It’s a joy to visit, and we’re reluctant to leave. Edwards has presented us with a version that is true to the spirit of the book, respects and builds on adaptations past, and conjures joyful memories and wishes for Christmases long gone.

If you’re not happy with Big Finish’s Box of Delights, well that’s just the Purple Pim!

The Box of Delights is out now from Big Finish.


  1. Thank you so much for getting in touch and letting us know that this review was helpful to you. It’s always great to hear from like minded fans, and I hope that you have a truly spiffing Christmas!

  2. Having read Paul Regans review, I opted to go out and purchase this new adaptation of John Masefields classic Christmas story.
    I began listening to it this week on a cold and frosty morning , which being only a month and a half from Christmas seemed entirely appropriate. I was not in the least bit disappointed, the production is superb and being a passionate devotee of the BBC 1984 production, I felt they stayed within reach of everything which made that such a magical and enthralling drama. I would agree with Paul in that the voice of Maria is on occasions straying into the tones of an adult doing a child’s impression, but given that the character of Maria being so strong and feisty then it is somehow acceptable, but could have been a little more realistic.
    Mark Gatiss is outstanding as Abnor Brown, chilling to listen to and brings a wonderful dark depth to the drama. I did feel that rat could have had a little more menace and ‘dirt’ in his voice, to capture the feeling of repulsion which his character needs.
    Lastly my preference would have been a more resounding version of o come all ye faithful in the tatchester cathedral for Christmas eve, it needed a full on cathedral choir and the wonderful reverberation which naturally comes with such an environment there’s a 1000 and 1 recordings out there which surely could have been used to uplift the closing scene to the triumphant climax which it undoubtedly reached.
    Overall I was really overjoyed to be taken through the magic of this story once again and my second treat will be to listen to it with my 10yr old son who is already feeling excited to hear it.
    Thanks once again to Paul Regan’s review and all the production team and actors at the Big Finish Company, you’ve given me a wonderful pre Christmas treat.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: